John: Poolside Miracle

Sermon by Derek Thomas on January 22, 2003

John 5:1-15

Poolside Miracle
John 5:1-15

After these things there was a feast of the Jews and Jesus
went up to Jerusalem. Now there is in Jerusalem a sheep gate a pool which is
called in Hebrew, Bethesda, having five porticos. In these lay a
multitude of those who were sick, blind, lame and withered waiting for the
moving of the waters. For an angel of the Lord went down at certain seasons into
the pool and stirred up the water. Whoever then first after the stirring up of
the water, stepped in was made well from whatever disease with which he was
afflicted. And a certain man was there who had been thirty-eight years in his
sickness. When Jesus saw him lying there and knew that he had already been along
time in that condition, He said to him, “Do you wish to get well?” The sick man
answered Him, “Sir, I have no man to put me into the pool when the water is
stirred up. But while I am coming, another steps down before me.” Jesus said to
him, “Arise, take up your pallet and walk.” And immediately the man became well
and took up his pallet and began to walk. Now it was the Sabbath on that day.
Therefore the Jews were saying to him who was cured, “It is the Sabbath and it
is not permissible for you to carry your pallet.” But he answered them, “He who
made me well was the one who said to me, ‘Take up your pallet and walk.’” They
asked him, “Who is the man who said to you, “Take up your pallet and walk?” But
he who was healed did not know who it was. For Jesus had slipped away while
there was a crowd in that place. Afterward Jesus found him in the temple and
said to him, “Behold, you have become well. Do not sin anymore so that nothing
worse may befall you.” The man went away and told the Jews that it was Jesus who
had made him well. Let’s pray together.

Father, we thank you for this beautiful story, and we
pray now this evening with the help of Your Spirit that we might profit from our
time together, from our time in your word, and for this time of prayer and
fellowship. We ask it in Jesus’ name. Amen.

Now John tells us, as we’ve had occasion to point out
before, towards the end of the gospel, one of the reasons why he writes this
gospel and why he chooses some of the stories that he includes in this gospel,
is that in order that those who read his gospel might believe. It’s an
evangelistic tract. That’s why, I suppose, Billy Graham and folk like that have
told young converts to go and read the gospel of John because John gives
testimony after testimony as to who Jesus is and why Jesus came into this world.
John tells us, in fact, that if all the incidents were to be included in the
book that all the books in the world wouldn’t have been sufficient.

It’s not hard for us to surmise why John would
include this particular story. It would be interesting but futile, of course, to
ponder some of the stories that weren’t included but why was this one included?
That’s fairly obvious, I think, because the clue is that this story is a
paradigm for the way in which Jesus comes into the lives of those who are
destitute, of those who are unable to do anything for themselves, and transforms
their lives. Isn’t that what Jesus has done for you?

I. Man’s hopeless condition.
I want to look at the story because it unfolds, I think, in
five stages. This is a Calvinistic sermon; it has five points. The first of
which is the hopelessness of this man’s condition
. We are told in verse five
that this man had been sick for 38 years. He had some kind of paralysis. He was
unable to move by himself; he was unable to get others to get him to this pool,
as the waters were stirred, apparently some spring broke forth disturbed in the
first place by an angel, we are told–whatever all that means. The first one into
this pool would be healed. Now, I don’t understand that. That’s part of the
miracle narrative of the first century of the time of Jesus. The point is that
this man was unable to get to the waters because someone else would get there
first and receive the blessing. He’s been in this condition for 38 years. That’s
a long time. This isn’t something recent that might in the ordinary process of
events begin to unravel into some quality of life. It’s something that’s been
with him for almost four decades.

In a sense it’s further underlined for us in the way
John goes on to say that this man was in the presence of the very one who could
do something about it, but he doesn’t know that or appreciate that. Indeed, at
the end of the story, he doesn’t even know who it is who had healed him. He
doesn’t even seem to know his name. This is a picture of someone who, in an
altogether hopeless condition, can do absolutely nothing for himself. It’s a
kind of parable, isn’t it? A kind of parable of the human condition.

The fascinating thing about it is that though this
man is surrounded by people in very similar conditions–some blind and some are
lame and some are paralyzed–what John wants us to see is that the amazing thing
is that Jesus comes to this man. He selects this man. He shines the light of His
grace and mercy upon this man. Perhaps this is the very worst case of all of all
the images of destitution and dereliction around Him; this was the worse
possible case–this man. And Jesus uses him to teach something of the amazing
quality of His grace and mercy.

You see, there could hardly be a better way to
illustrate the principle that the salvation that you and I enjoy in Jesus Christ
is a salvation that He provides, that He gives. In a sense there is something of
the operation of the absolute sovereignty of Christ in the healing of this man.

You know, I suppose had this man lived in our time
and had he had a hymnbook and a pianist, he might have sung some of the hymns
that you and I love to sing. I love gospel hymns. You know tunes and hymns are
married together, until death us do part in my book. There are certain tunes
that are married to certain words and as soon as you hear the tune, the words of
a hymn come into your mind. “Amazing grace, how sweet the sound that saved a
wretch like me.” Don’t you think those words might have become familiar to him
had he lived in our time?

When the Puritan Lord Berta was visiting Warwick
Castle, one of the sights to see, a beautiful castle still in very good order,
in late 17th century or so, and when the local magistrate heard that
he was there asked him to visit the prison. And there were three prisoners who
were facing execution the next morning. George Burta went in to visit them and
talked with them and tells of one of the prisoners, and this is what the
prisoner said to him, “I never killed anyone; I never hurt anybody. I hope the
Lord will have mercy upon me.” And this alarmed George Burta because the man had
committed a crime and had been found guilty of the crime and he was going to pay
the consequences of his crime, but he still wasn’t willing to confess it even
though he was dying the next day. And even on his way towards the platform where
he would be hung, the Puritan yelled out to him, “Please sir, don’t trust in
your own righteousness. Look to Christ!” And those were the last words that man
ever heard. Well, here’s a man in this story who is in an absolutely hopeless

II. Secondly, the unexpectedness
of Jesus’ question
In verse six, we are told that when Jesus saw him lying there and
knew that he had already been a long time in that condition, He said to him, “Do
you wish to get well?” Now stop a moment. Here’s a man who’s been sick,
paralyzed for 38 years, and Jesus is asking him the question, “Do you wish to
get well?” Sometimes, when we read the Scriptures, there are sentences that
just, as you Americans say, ‘Blow you away.’ This is one of them. Of course
he wants to get well. Who wouldn’t want to get well. Who wouldn’t want to be
healed from this paralysis. And yet, our Lord, the perfect pastor that He was,
who knows how to put His finger right on the pulse of where we are, was perhaps
asking the very question this man needed to hear, because it is possible, isn’t
it, after 38 years, to have so grown used to our condition, to have so begun to
depend on others to do things for us, to so perhaps lose faith entirely in the
very possibility of getting better, that perhaps the question that he needed to
hear the most was as to whether or not he had any desire left to get better.

You see, it’s not a stupid question. It’s not as
silly a question as it may at first appear. Because I think Jesus is driving at
something that’s at the very heart of this man’s problem. His problem was more
than just his physical paralysis. His problem lay deep-rooted in his will and
psyche. He was at the place where healing was possible. He was in the presence
of the one who could make that healing possible, and it’s possible to be in this
place and to choose not to have the blessing.

Do you follow what I’m saying? It’s possible to be
in the company of God’s people, under the sound of His word, and choose not
receive the blessing. And John is including this story, you see, because the
question that Jesus asks him is the very question that this gospel confronts us
with. Jesus is able to transform through personal repentance and forgiveness,
and the transforming power of His Spirit, and the question is, “Do we desire
it. Do we want it. Do you want to be made whole?” That’s the issue. It’s the
issue in evangelism every time. Do you really want to be made whole?

For more than 20 years, Professor Edwin Keaty of the
University of Pennsylvania Law School, used to start his classes by writing on
a blackboard two numbers, the numbers 2 and 4. And then he would ask his
audience, “What’s the solution?” And, one student would shout out, “6” and
another student would shout out, “2” and another student would shout out, “8”
and Professor Keaty would shake his head and he would say, “Gentlemen, unless
you know what the problem is, you cannot possibly find the answer.” The problem
that this man was facing was more than physical paralysis. The problem this man
was facing was desire. Do you want to get well? Do you really want the
blessing? I’m almost tempted to stop right there. Because maybe that’s our
problem here. Can I say that? Do we have a problem here at First Presbyterian
Church, of any description? Of course. Every church does. Maybe the real
issue is one of desire. Do we really want to be filled with God’s Spirit,
because if we are, we will never be the same. Life won’t be the same. Our
homes won’t be the same. Our marriages won’t be the same. Our children won’t
be the same. Our church won’t be the same. Our priorities won’t be the same.
Our schedules won’t be the same. That’s the question. Do you want to get

III. Thirdly, the power of Jesus’
Jesus says to him in verse 8, and it’s one of these wonderful
statements that you find in the gospels, “Arise, take up your pallet,” or take
up your bed, or your mat that you would roll up, “and walk.” Arise, take up
your pallet and walk. You have to try to put yourself in the picture here, of a
man whose been paralyzed for 38 years. There’s a sense in which this is cruel,
isn’t there? Because if Jesus were saying that, and it was utterly dependent
upon this man to obey it, it would be the height of cruelty to say to him,
“Arise, take up your pallet and walk.” But this is Jesus who is speaking, this
is “the Word who was with God and was God, and became flesh and dwelt among us
and we beheld His glory.” This is the Word who made the heavens and earth, and
remember, John puts it in the negative in the opening prologue, “There wasn’t
anything that was made that wasn’t made with Him.” He made everything. The
Creator is standing before this man. The One who said, “Let there be light,”
and there was light. The One who formed and fashioned the universe, the stars,
and the planets.

My son and I and Rosemary and the dog were out this
past week looking at the space station. You know, you can see it going across
the sky. You can go to a website and they’ll tell you exactly what time it
appears. It’s only there for about five or six minutes, and it goes across the
sky. They’ll give you a map with stars, and directions, and tell you what time
it will appear. And sure enough, we were all out there, and the dog is looking
up at the sky, and this little orange glow appears and travels across the sky
until it hits the earth’s shadow and then disappears. Staggering. And you
can’t help, but you’re looking at this, and the stars that are beyond it and
some of them are twinkling, and we got the telescope out and saw Saturn’s rings,
just phenomenal stuff. Jesus made all of it. Jesus simply called it into
being. And He’s saying to this man, “Arise, take up your bed and walk.” He
doesn’t say to him, “Now, exercise three years of penitential prayer. Send Me
fifty dollars and I’ll send you a handkerchief that I’ve blessed.” Jesus
doesn’t do that sort of thing. When Jesus heals, He heals with a word of

That’s why C.S. Lewis said that those who say Jesus
was only a moral teacher, are on the same plane as the man who says he’s a
poached egg. Either Jesus is a lunatic or else He is God, because of the things
that He says. And He says to this man who’s been paralyzed 38 years, “Arise,
take up your bed and walk.” Jesus only needs to speak a word, and it is done.
That’s the power of the Jesus that we worship, as we come to Christmas. The One
who’s lying in the manger is the sovereign Lord of heaven and earth.

IV. Fourthly, the bitterness of
Jewish opposition.
We have comedy and tragedy linked together in this story.
“Pick up your mat and walk,” Jesus says, and here he is walking through
Jerusalem. Now, if a man has been paralyzed for 38 years, and he’s been in
Jerusalem all that time, everybody in Jerusalem knows it. They know what he
looks like. They know his name. When they see him walking with a mat tucked
under his arm, looking as pleased as punch, unable to contain himself no doubt,
singing at the time of his voice, shouting to people, “Look at me,” I know, I’m
adlibbing. But they recognized him, and what do they say? What’s the first
word that comes out of their mouths? Turn to verse 10, I’ll read it to you.
“It is the Sabbath.” Isn’t that amazing. Here’s a man who has been healed
after being crippled and paralyzed for 38 years, and the Jews of Jerusalem can
only think of one thing: it’s the Sabbath. You see, they had written a book on
the Sabbath, and it was called, The Sabbath and How Not to Break It. And Jesus
was writing, before their eyes, another book, and it was called, The Sabbath and
How to Enjoy It. The book they had written said, in chapter 4, paragraph 6,
section 15, subsection 347, “No mat carrying on the Sabbath.” But actually
that’s not what the Old Testament had said. The Old Testament had said that you
must not do any unnecessary work on the Lord’s Day. No carrying loads in order
to make profit on the Sabbath. But it was the Lord’s Day, and one of the
prophecies of Isaiah 35 was, to the effect, that on the Lord’s Day the lame
would leap for joy. They had no joy, because they knew nothing about grace.
You see, without grace law become legalism, without an enjoyment of grace,
without knowledge of the forgiveness of sins coursing through our veins. Do you
see what this says about the Jews in Jerusalem. They couldn’t give anything for
this man or his sickness, or his disease, that’s not what they cared about.
They didn’t care. And that says a whole lot about them. All they were
concerned about was, “No mat carrying on Sunday.”

Well my dear friends, I’ve met Christians just like
those. And I’m saying that as one who upholds the abiding sanction and law of
the Fourth Commandment, what these people are saying is, “I don’t care about the
lost.” Do you remember what Paul says, 2 Corinthians 5, “From now on, we regard
no one from a worldly point of view.” His burden all along was to see men and
women brought to a saving faith in Jesus Christ. That’s my concern.

V. Fifthly, and finally, the
challenge of Jesus’ exhortation.
It’s fascinating. Jesus finds him in the temple, and in verse
14, this is what He says to him: “Behold, you have become well. Do not sin
anymore that nothing worse may befall you.” Stop sinning, or something worse
may befall you. I don’t think, though commentators are divided, that Jesus is
necessarily saying that the reason for this man’s paralysis is that he had
sinned in some way. That’s not the inference that we’re meant to draw. What we
are meant to learn is that the evidence that this man has truly come to know who
Jesus is and loves Him with all his heart, the evidence of that, of a changed
heart, of a converted life, of a regenerate soul, the evidence of that will be
that he will not go on sinning anymore. Not that he will be sinless, but that
his desire will be that he be free from sin.

Now let me issue that as a challenge. Of all the
things that you long for the most, I wonder if that’s right up there as number
one? “I wish, I wish with all my heart, that I didn’t keep sinning. I wish with
all my heart that I would never sin again.” Because that is the mark of a
regenerate person. That’s the mark of someone who is in love with Jesus
Christ. Do you remember how Augustine so self revealingly put it? “Give me
chastity, but not yet.” And I wonder, if we secretly have within our hearts a
similar desire, because we are too much in love with the world, and not
sufficiently in love with Jesus. I want above everything else, to be like
Jesus. Let’s pray together.

Our Father in heaven, we thank You now for this beautiful, astonishing story,
full of twists and turns as it is, and we pray that our greatest longing and
desire might be that we might be more like You. We know that one day we shall
be like You and we shall see You even as You are, but today we are too conscious
of our own sin and our own failure and our selfishness and our own greed, and
our own desire to do what is right in our own eyes. We pray, Holy Spirit,
transform us and mold us and shape us more and more into the image of Christ,
for Jesus’ sake we ask it, Amen.

© 2019 First Presbyterian Church.

This transcribed message has been lightly edited and formatted for the Web site. No attempt has been made, however, to alter the basic extemporaneous delivery style, or to produce a grammatically accurate, publication-ready manuscript conforming to an established style template.

Should there be questions regarding grammar or theological content, the reader should presume any website error to be with the webmaster/transcriber/editor rather than with the original speaker. For full copyright, reproduction and permission information, please visit the First Presbyterian Church Copyright, Reproduction & Permission statement.

To view recordings of our entire services, visit our Facebook page.

Print This Post